Daniel and I recently undertook a quick weekend getaway to Fredonia, New York. I’ve been aware of Fredonia for decades, and we drove through there four years ago on our way to Niagara Falls. But it was only recently that I felt the pull to visit, as several branches of my mother’s side of the family tree intertwined there during the 19th and early 20th centuries. Prior to the visit, I did some research, drawing on what I already knew of my family’s genealogy and available information about Fredonia and its residents.
My fourth-great-grandfather, Zattu Cushing, was one of the town’s founders. Two of his grandchildren, Alonzo and William B. Cushing, were Civil War heroes and their service photos grace our home’s threshold along with other family members who served.
Another branch on my mother’s side, the
Swetland family, has ties to northeast Ohio — both
in the Swetland
Building in downtown Cleveland, and the lawsuit
the family filed to try and prevent the creation of
Cuyahoga County Airport. My
second-great-grandfather, Horace Monroe Swetland, is interred at Forest Hill
Cemetery in Fredonia, as is his wife Clara.
Horace founded a
publishing company which, for a time, owned The
American Architect periodical. Judging by the crypt they were buried in, not
to mention a very considerable sum she bequeathed her three children when she
died, the company must have been quite lucrative. Clara’s daughter Velma married my
great-grandfather, Frederic Cushing Stevens, and they had two children: my
grandfather, and his sister — also named Velma.
My great-grandmother, great-grandfather, and grandfather are all
interred in the Stevens family plot which is just behind the Swetland
crypt. Also interred in the Stevens plot
are my great-grandfather’s father, Douglas Houghton* Stevens (1835–1908), along
with his wife Sarah (1842-1925) and their daughter Elizabeth (1868-1961), who
never married.
All of the above, however, is background,
further detailed in the video at the bottom of this post.
We arrived at Forest Hill cemetery and almost
immediately upon entry we found the memorial to the Cushing brothers. They are well remembered in Fredonia and
continue to be memorialized not just at the cemetery but with a street named
for the family and with banners. We also
spotted a Drake monument with three graves, but my attempts at research led to
multiple dead ends and to the best of my knowledge they bear no relation to me. Finally, we found the Stevens and Swetland
area, and it was here that my heart sank.
The stained-glass windows in the Swetland crypt were broken, leaving the
interior exposed to the open air. The grave
marker for my grandfather, who died in 1954, was in very poor shape — covered
in lichen, with the letters nearly indecipherable. What a sad fate for two once wealthy,
prominent families.
I had to put my feelings aside for a while as
we had more searching to do. At the
other end of the cemetery were still more distant ancestors: my
third-great-grandfather Philo Hull Stevens (1803-1865) along with his wife
Catherine Putnam Cushing (1808-1887).
She was the daughter of Zattu Cushing and the aunt of the heroic Cushing
brothers — making them my first cousins five times removed. It took some searching and it was Daniel who
found the monument, their inscriptions barely legible after over a century of
wear.
While we were there, the 21st century made
itself known with a notification from my cell phone: Martin, the co-owner of Edwards Waterhouse Inn let
us know that our room was ready and if we were nearby we could check in early
at no extra charge. It was just a four-minute
drive, and we were soon at the elegant, beautifully restored Queen Anne home. We checked-in and set things up in our room
before heading back out.
Cold, hungry, and a bit crestfallen, Daniel
and I stopped by El
Negocio 2, a local Puerto Rican restaurant on West Main
Street. Our server was a nice young man
from Ponce, himself new to the Fredonia area.
While refueling with lunch, I became determined to do something about
the situation. So, we asked our server where
the nearest general store was and he directed us to one. I bought a soft-bristled brush and some
water, we returned to the cemetery, and I brushed the lichen off the headstones
of my grandfather, along with my second-great grandfather, his wife, and their
daughter.
With that accomplished, my mood lifted. Daniel and I decided to drive around the Chautauqua
County area to get the lay of the land.
Daniel observed that some of the towns seemed like types of places one
would go to disappear and live off the grid.
We returned to downtown Fredonia and walked the core area, stopping by a
few stores and picking up a few guidebooks.
One mentioned another nearby town, Jamestown, birthplace of Lucille
Ball, which is a potential weekend getaway for next summer. Later that evening we went to Mrs. Fred’s for
dinner. Our delightful waitress, Emily,
had some amusing gossip about the town.
Along with our dinner I had a couple of fine locally made ciders, prior
to which Emily told me their bar had “everything except Old Fashioneds,” which
I found ironic because that was my grandfather’s preferred drink.
After a restful sleep and a cooked breakfast
courtesy of Martin the innkeeper, Daniel and I made a final trip to the
cemetery so I could film a short video.
Then we were on our way back home.
*My maternal great-grandfather’s father was
named Douglas Houghton Stevens. My
fifth-great-grandfather on my father’s side, William Drake, was married
to a Mary
Houghton. Her
father, Colonel
Joab Houghton, fought with General George Washington at the
Battles of Long Island, Harlem Heights, and Hoyt Plains in New York during the
Revolutionary War. An amateur
genealogist in the family discovered this coincidence shortly after my father died in 2016 and posited that my parents were distantly related. However, further research indicates Douglas
Houghton Stevens was named in honor of his paternal aunt's famous husband, Dr.
Douglass Houghton, whose paternal line stems from the Houghton family of
Massachusetts; whereas Col. Joab Houghton's line stems from a separate New
Jersey Houghton family. Further, modern
genealogical and Y-DNA research established that they are distinct families and
bear no blood relation to each other.
Thus, the ten-year notion that my parents were distant relatives was
erroneous.
.jpg)





























